- both had beards
- both wore sandals (or similar)
- both claimed to have received a revelation
- both point to another as the object of worship
- both responsible for ‘holy’ text
- both understood by many
- both misunderstood by many
- both had serious thoughts about women
- Paul thought they had certain roles & offices available to them
- Muhammad received the revelation that more than 3 should be available to him
- both were really important in the growth and formation of a world religion
- both had interesting gifts in knowledge and education
- Paul was an amazing writer and remarkably clever
- Muhammad was apparently illiterate but obviously had been exposed to other peoples knowledge – he too was remarkably clever
- both were amazing but flawed leaders
- both were responsible for the death of people who didn’t believe as they did
- Paul bore this responsibility before the revelation
- Muhammad bore this responsibility after the revelation
- both had a belief in a Jesus figure
- Paul encountered Jesus on a road within 6 years of Jesus’ death and resurrection
- Muhammad heard about ‘Jesus’ in a cave 600 years after Jesus lived, died and rose from the dead
- on the road – Paul was asked by Jesus “Why are you persecuting me?”
- in the cave – Muhammad was informed ‘Jesus’ didn’t even die – 600 years after the fact
- Paul, after the revelation began to preach that Jesus was the Son of God
- Muhammad, after the revelation began to teach that Jesus wasn’t the Son of God
- Paul is accused of inventing a religion – Christianity
- Muhammad’s words about Allah making it only look like Jesus died, if true, seems like it would have lead to the invention of a religion – Christianity
- both were questioned about their authority after the revelation
- Paul used sarcasm and self deprecation
- Muhammad used persuasion, fear of hell fire and the sword
- Paul before his revelation thought the idea of a defeated, crucified messenger of God scandalous
- Muhammad after his revelation thought the idea of a defeated, crucified messenger of God scandalous
- Paul came to realise that God’s strength is revealed in the weakness of men
- Muhammad came to realise that God’s strength is revealed in the strength of men
- the core of Paul’s faith is belief in God and his divine Messiah Jesus
- the core of Muhammad’s faith is belief in Allah and his prophet Muhammad
- Paul – reflecting on his future death, said “to be absent from the body was to be with the LORD”
- Muhammad, reflecting on his future death, was unsure if he would escape the hell fire
- the writings of Paul in many ways explain to the world what Christ has achieved and what a christian looks like and lives like
- the writings about Muhammad in every way tells the world how to live – from how and when and where to pray, to how to go to the toilet
- Paul called Christians to imitate him – in a Christ oriented life – not copy his everyday actions
- Muhammad called Muslims to imitate him – in an Allah oriented life and copy his everyday actions
- Paul sang songs of worship to the LORD
- Muhammad – not so much
- Christian tradition says Paul was beheaded
- Islamic tradition says Muhammad appointed a judge who beheaded a great great number of enemies
- Paul was killed by Nero – possibly – probably
- Muhammad was killed by a young woman – possibly – probably
- Paul patently knew indepth the Jewish scriptures – this is evident from his writings
- Muhammad patently knew a very limited amount of the Jewish scriptures – this is evident from the Qu’ran
- the scriptures that Paul wrote reflect his thoughts, gifts and are superintended by God
- the ‘scriptures’ that Muhammad received do not reflect his thoughts, gifts and are superprovided by God
- when Paul quoted pagan ideas in his writings he named them as such
- when Muhammad received mythological stories in the quranic revelation they are not named as such
- Paul said Satan hindered him from visiting Thessalonica
- Muhammad said Satan fooled him with some verses which he initially thought were from God
- Paul is much loved by Christians
- Muhammad is adored by Muslims
Category Archives: Paul
Contrasts & Paradoxes
Today I want to begin a series of Contrasts and Paradoxes. As is usually the case the piec comes from someone else but was a blessing to me and I hope it may be a blessing to you. I love contrasts because in positioning two things together or against each other – each one is better understood on its own terms and alongside something else. The first in the series is Jesus & Paul. Who Paul? – you say. Paul – the Saint & Apostle – you must have heard of him). Damascus? 2000 or so years ago? Anyone? Anyone? Anyone? Bueller?
“Paul ran from Christ; Christ pursued and overtook him. Paul resisted Christ; Christ disarmed him. Paul persecuted Christ; Christ converted him. Paul was an alien; Christ made him a member of the family. Paul was an enemy; Christ made him a friend. Paul was ‘in the flesh’; Christ set him ‘in the Spirit.’ Paul was under the law; Christ set him in grace. Paul was dead; Christ made him alive to God. How does one give reasons for this? He does not give reasons; he sings, ‘Blessed be God who blessed us . . . even as he chose us in him.’”
Lewis B. Smedes, Union With Christ (Grand Rapids, 1983), pages 86-87.
HT (hat tip) Ray Ortlund at Christ is Deeper Still